22 May 2011


From Russell Moore via Vitamin Z.
On the nightstand of a woman in your church, there’s a Christian romance novel and a Bible. Does that matter? On the Kindle of a teenage Christian woman in your congregation’s youth group, there’s a “young adult” fiction bestseller. Should that concern you?
A new book by Boston University researchers Ogi Ogas and Sai Gaddam, A Billion Wicked Thoughts, offers a disturbing look at how Internet search engines reveal much about the sexual and emotional desires of men and women, and how they differ. The research confirms in some ways what almost everyone knows: men are visually engaged, attracted to youth and sexual novelty, and are thus vulnerable to visual pornography.
The research explores further what the commercialized romance industry tells us about what it means to be a woman (at least in a fallen world). Women are much less likely to be drawn to visual pornography (although more do so than one might think), but are quite likely to be involved in such media as Internet romantic fiction or the old-fashioned romance novel.
The romance novel follows, the researchers argue, a typical pattern. The hero is almost never, they say, a blue collar worker, a bureaucrat, or someone in the traditionally feminine occupations (hairdresser, kindergarten teacher, etc.). He is competent, confident, and usually wealthy. He is, in short, an alpha male.
But, they argue, this alpha male is typically a rough character who learns to be tamed into kindness, kindness to her. Thus, you wind up with not only the strong silent cowboys with the soft interior life, but also these days vampires and werewolves and Vikings.
And all of this is moving toward the climax of the romance story: the “happily-ever-after.”
“Romance novels rarely have a sequel,” the book concludes. “Once the hero and heroine are joined in love or matrimony, they get their Happily-Ever-After, presumably with a bevy of children and domestic bliss. Further adventures would violate the female fantasy of true, committed, eternal love.”
“Though there are many series of modern romance novels, once a couple gets their Happily-Ever-After in one book, they only resurface as beloved supporting characters in future books, with each subsequent book’s focus on a new hero or heroine.”
Of course, as they do with pornography, these scholars explain all of these archetypal female desires in a Darwinian need for the woman to seek out a mate who can be simultaneously monogamous and protective of the offspring. This evolutionary desire is seen in the strong male who pours out his feelings of devotion, and whose lifelong commitment is frozen in time and certainty in the Happily-Ever-After moment.
While I don’t share all the presuppositions of these scholars, I think they’re on to something about the allure of the commercialized romance story. Pornography and romance novels aren’t (or at least aren’t always) morally equivalent, but they “work” the same way.
Both are based on an illusion. Pornography is based on the illusion of a perfectly willing, always aroused partner without the “work” of relational intimacy. Often romance novels or their film equivalents do the same thing for the emotional needs of women that pornography offers for the erotic urges of men.
And in both cases, what the “market” wants is sameness. Men want the illusion of women who look just like women but are, in terms of sexual response, just like men. Women want the illusion of men who are “real” men, but, in terms of a concept of romance, are just like women. In both artificial eros and artificial romance, there is the love of the self, not the mystery of the other.
Thankfully, we do not yet have a market for “Christian” pornography (but just wait, someone will find a way). But we do have a market for “Christian” romance novels. Now some of those classified as such aren’t really “romance novels” at all. They’re complicated looks at the human condition, especially male/female relationships, from a Christian vantage point.
A lot of this genre, though, is simply a Christianization of a form not intended to enhance intimacy but to escape to an artificial illusion of it. Granted, there’s no graphic sexuality here. The hero and heroine don’t sleep together; they pray together. But that’s just the point.
How many disappointed middle-aged women in our congregations are reading these novels as a means of comparing the “strong spiritual leaders” depicted there with what by comparison must seem to be underachieving lumps lying next to them on the couch?
This is not to equate morally “romance novels” with the grave soul destruction of pornography. But it is worth asking, “Is what I’m consuming leading me toward contentment with my spouse (or future spouse) or away from it? Is it pointing me to the other in one-flesh union or to an eroticized embodiment of my own desires? Is this the mystery or a mirage?


Bryn said...

amen, bet.

abdulbaseer said...

Being a Muslim I can only say: We have faith in what has been revealed towards us and revealed towards you; our God and your God is one, and to Him we have submitted.

Susan S said...

That was a very thought-provoking post, especially the question, "Is what I’m consuming leading me toward contentment with my spouse (or future spouse) or away from it?" It is easy to see the way pornography leads to discontentment with a spouse but I'd never considered romance novels in that way. You've made a very good point!

Anil Rajanala said...

Me gusta mucho tu blog .. colores muy agradable y tema. ¿Hizo usted mismo sitio web o que usted contrata a alguien que lo haga por ti? Plz respuesta de nuevo como yo estoy buscando para crear mi propio blog y me gustaría saber donde te tienen que esto. aplausos

Web hosting

Elena said...

Nice blog
It was nice article

iriske said...

Very interesting. Keep working.
Maybe you can visit my wedding dress site, too.

Anil Rajanala said...

Wow that was odd. I just wrote an very long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t appear. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyways, just wanted to say wonderful blog!
Web hosting

Anonymous said...

You're right on! Reading romance and watching soap operas are as poisonous to a marriage as porn in many ways. The best way to stay happily married and sexually fulfilled? Thank God every night for your spouse, listing as many positive qualities as you can. Ask God to bless your spouse, and to help you resolve and issues that you are having. Then say amen, tell your spouse you love them and why, and get some good loven'! lol.

Inspector Clouseau said...

Nice work. I came across your blog while “blog surfing” using the Next Blog button on the blue Nav Bar located at the top of my blogger.com site. I frequently just travel around looking for other blogs which exist on the Internet, and the various, creative ways in which people express themselves. Thanks for sharing.

Benjamin Joseph said...

there is good in it, if a man is willing to watch romantic comedies or something tolerable where the displays of his wife's heart are but she cannot put it into words then he can see how to keep chasing her wonderful heart with methods that make her feel how ever women feel that is good lol I am a husband after all I just try to the best I know how. Books and fantasy may be escape for some but its insight for those with the right heart and Father God with Jesus to show us the way. Nice perspective though and thank you for sharing yourself here and opening up for the world to see the light within.


sandstorm said...

Thanks for sharing your great blog. Really enjoyed reading about what you have been up to. I am always interested in reading other peoples religous views and thoughts. Please come take a look at my blogs if you get the chance. It would be greatly appreciated.

Thanks and God Bless

Building Regulations for Conservatories

Building Regulations

elizabeth said...

right on. i was in a book club and we were reading some book that i just had to shelve- well, get rid of bc my kids are avid readers and i didn't want them to find it:)
the ladies in the book club thought i was strange. i just said "i don't need that book leading my thoughts in such a dangerous direction" i guess i am easily influenced in that way. and returning to real life would make me bitter via comparison.